Lucid Trading vs TradeDay - Prop Firm Comparison
Introduction
Lucid Trading and TradeDay are two CME futures firms that both treat fast, trader-friendly payouts as a headline feature, which makes for a close matchup. TradeDay, a Chicago firm operating since 2020, offers day-one payouts with no consistency requirement, up to six simultaneous accounts, no activation fee, and a profit split that starts at 80% and climbs to 95%, all across 6+ asset classes. Lucid Trading counters with the fastest average payout in the industry at around 15 minutes, paid via Plaid, ADP or cryptocurrency, a 50,000+ trader community and a 10+ platform lineup. Both fund CME index, energy and metals contracts on a one-step-style evaluation with no hard time limit. The structures diverge in the details. Lucid runs LucidFlex (five qualifying days) and LucidPro (a single-day pass) with static max-loss limits and a flat 90% split. TradeDay uses a single-step sim evaluation with a trailing drawdown, but layers on perks like six concurrent accounts and a 95% split ceiling. On entry, Lucid starts lower at $25K versus TradeDay’s $50K. The deciding factors are split ceiling and payout style: TradeDay’s path to 95% and day-one withdrawals appeal to scaled traders running multiple accounts, while Lucid’s 15-minute crypto payouts, single-day evaluation and broader platform list appeal to traders who value speed and flexibility. A trader who wants multiple accounts and a 95% ceiling will lean toward TradeDay; one who wants the fastest withdrawals and crypto options will prefer Lucid Trading.
Quick Comparison |
|---|
| Feature | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
|  |  |
| Founded | Specialist futures firm (year not publicly stated) | 2020 (Chicago) |
| Trustpilot Rating | 4.7/5 (3,298 reviews) | 4.6/5 (1,354 reviews) |
| Trading Focus | CME futures | CME futures (6+ asset classes) |
| Profit Split | 90% (100% on first $10K, early LucidPro) | 80% from day one, up to 95% |
| Evaluation | 1-Step (LucidFlex, LucidPro) | Single-step (sim evaluation) |
| Account Sizes | $25K – $150K | $50K – $150K |
| Payout Speed | 15-minute average (fastest) | Day-one payouts, no consistency rule |
| Review | Read full review | Read full review |
Key Differences Between Lucid Trading and TradeDay
- Payout style: Lucid documents ~15-minute payouts with crypto options; TradeDay offers day-one payouts with no consistency requirement.
- Profit split: Lucid pays a flat 90%; TradeDay starts at 80% and scales to 95%.
- Multiple accounts: TradeDay allows up to six simultaneous accounts with no activation fee; Lucid funds per plan.
- Drawdown: Lucid uses static max-loss limits; TradeDay uses a trailing drawdown.
- Platforms: Lucid supports 10+ platforms; TradeDay covers major futures platforms across 6+ asset classes.
- Entry: Lucid starts lower at $25K; TradeDay starts at $50K.
- Scale: Lucid has 50,000+ traders and $60M+ paid; TradeDay has operated since 2020.
- Payout methods: Lucid adds cryptocurrency withdrawals; TradeDay focuses on day-one access.
Program Types – Which experience fits your goals? |
|---|
| Program | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Evaluation Format | Single-step (LucidFlex, LucidPro) | Single-step (sim evaluation) |
| Fast Pass | LucidPro can pass in a single trading day | Day-one payouts after funding |
| Static-Drawdown Option | Static max-loss limits | Not offered; trailing model |
| Account Variants | LucidFlex, LucidPro | Single track, up to 6 accounts |
| Consistency Rule | 50% (LucidFlex), 40% on payouts (LucidPro) | None |
Assessment Criteria – How can you pass the test? |
|---|
| Criteria | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Profit Target | About 6% (LucidFlex); 5-6% (LucidPro) | Single-step target (see firm site) |
| Daily Loss Limit | None (LucidFlex); scaled by size (LucidPro) | Trailing-based limits |
| Maximum Loss | Static max loss (about 3-4% by size) | Trailing drawdown |
| Minimum Trading Days | 5 qualifying days (LucidFlex); none (LucidPro) | None specified |
| Time Limit | None | None |
| News Trading | Permitted within plan rules | Permitted within rules |
Fees and Pricing – How much will you pay? |
|---|
| Option | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Pricing Model | Plan-based evaluation fee | Monthly subscription |
| Activation Fee | See firm site | None |
| Profit Split | 90% (100% on first $10K, early LucidPro) | 80% from day one, up to 95% |
| Payout Speed | 15-minute average | Day-one payouts |
| Simultaneous Accounts | Per plan | Up to 6 at once |
| Coupons | See discounts | Coupon Code |
Platforms/Tools – What can you use? |
|---|
| Platform | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Trading Platforms | CQG, Rithmic, NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Sierra Chart and more (10+) | Major futures platforms (6+ asset classes) |
| Data Feeds | CQG and Rithmic | Multiple data feeds |
| Mobile Trading | Via supported platform apps | Via supported platform apps |
| Automated Trading | Permitted within rules | Permitted within rules |
| Order-Flow Tools | Bookmap, ATAS, Jigsaw, Quantower | Multiple platform tools |
Available Markets/Products |
|---|
| Market | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Index Futures | ES, NQ, YM, RTY plus micros and NKD | ES, NQ, YM, RTY and CME index futures |
| Energy / Metals | CL, NG, GC, SI (CME) | CL, NG, GC, SI (CME) |
| Forex | CME FX futures | CME FX futures |
| Crypto | Not offered | Not offered |
| Micro Futures | CME micro contracts | CME micro contracts |
| Weekend Holding | Per CME session rules | Per CME session rules |
Technical Capabilities/Performance |
|---|
| Feature | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Execution | CQG and Rithmic execution | Established platform execution |
| Platform Breadth | 10+ platforms, among the broadest in futures | 6+ asset classes |
| Payout Speed | 15-minute average, fastest documented | Day-one payouts |
| Payout Record | $60M+ paid to 50,000+ traders | Established since 2020 |
| Automated Trading | Permitted within rules | Permitted within rules |
Support and Community |
|---|
| Support Feature | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Customer Support | Email and active community support | Email and responsive support |
| Trading Community | 50,000+ registered traders | Established US community |
| Educational Resources | Guides, tutorials and market resources | Beginner-friendly resources |
| Track Record | 4.7/5 from 3,298 reviews; $60M+ paid | 4.6/5 (1,354); since 2020 |
Conclusion and Final Recommendation |
|---|
| Key Element | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Strengths | Fastest payouts (15 min), crypto payouts, 10+ platforms, single-day LucidPro pass, lower $25K entry | Day-one payouts, no consistency rule, up to 6 accounts, no activation fee, 80-95% split, since 2020 |
| Weaknesses | Consistency rules on both plans, futures-only | 80% starting split, $50K minimum entry, futures-only |
| Best For | Traders who want the fastest withdrawals, crypto payouts and platform choice | Traders who want multiple accounts, day-one payouts and a 95% split ceiling |
Final Grade
How we rank firms ↗ | 8.4 | 8.9 |
| Discount Codes | See discounts | Coupon Code |
| Review | Read full review | Read full review |
FAQ
Which firm pays out faster, Lucid Trading or TradeDay?
Both prioritise speed. Lucid documents an average payout of around 15 minutes with Plaid, ADP and crypto options. TradeDay offers day-one payouts with no consistency requirement. Lucid wins on raw per-request speed; TradeDay wins on how soon and how freely you can start withdrawing.
Which firm has the higher profit split, Lucid or TradeDay?
It depends on scaling. Lucid pays a flat 90%, which beats TradeDay’s 80% starting point. TradeDay scales up to 95%, so a scaled TradeDay trader ends up ahead of Lucid’s flat rate.
Can I run multiple accounts with either firm?
TradeDay explicitly allows up to six simultaneous accounts with no activation fee. Lucid Trading funds per plan, so TradeDay is the better choice for traders who want to run several accounts at once.
How was this 2 companies Comparison Created?
This comparison was compiled using the published review data on JoinProp for each firm, along with each firm’s stated evaluation rules, account structures, platforms and payout terms as of 2026. Where a detail is not publicly disclosed, the cell notes this. Verify current terms directly with Lucid Trading and TradeDay before purchasing a challenge.
