Lucid Trading vs TradeDay - Prop Firm Comparison
Introduction
Lucid Trading and TradeDay are two CME futures firms that both treat fast, trader-friendly payouts as a headline feature, which makes for a close matchup. TradeDay, a Chicago firm operating since 2020, offers day-one payouts with no consistency requirement, up to six simultaneous accounts, no activation fee, and a profit split that starts at 80% and climbs to 95%, all across 6+ asset classes. Lucid Trading counters with the fastest average payout in the industry at around 15 minutes, paid via Plaid, ADP or cryptocurrency, a 50,000+ trader community and a 10+ platform lineup. Both fund CME index, energy and metals contracts on a one-step-style evaluation with no hard time limit. The structures diverge in the details. Lucid runs LucidFlex (five qualifying days) and LucidPro (a single-day pass) with static max-loss limits and a flat 90% split. TradeDay uses a single-step sim evaluation with a trailing drawdown, but layers on perks like six concurrent accounts and a 95% split ceiling. On entry, Lucid starts lower at $25K versus TradeDay’s $50K. The deciding factors are split ceiling and payout style: TradeDay’s path to 95% and day-one withdrawals appeal to scaled traders running multiple accounts, while Lucid’s 15-minute crypto payouts, single-day evaluation and broader platform list appeal to traders who value speed and flexibility. A trader who wants multiple accounts and a 95% ceiling will lean toward TradeDay; one who wants the fastest withdrawals and crypto options will prefer Lucid Trading.
TL;DR: Lucid Trading (grade 8.4) offers a 90 profit split; TradeDay (grade 8.9) offers 50/50 below $4,000; 80/20 above $4,000; 90/10 at Funded Live. Full side-by-side below, plus who each is best for. Our higher-rated pick: TradeDay (8.9 vs 8.4).
Quick Facts
| Feature | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
|  |  |
| Founded | — | — |
| Profit Split | 90 | 50/50 below $4,000; 80/20 above $4,000; 90/10 at Funded Live |
| Maximum Account Size | $150,000 | — |
| Evaluation Phases | 2 | 1 |
| Trustpilot Rating | 4.8 | 4.6 |
| Expert Grade | 8.4 | 8.9 |
Program Types
| Program | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Entry Level Program | Yes | Yes |
| Advanced Program | Yes | Yes |
| Scaling Options | Yes | Yes |
| Demo Account | — | Yes |
Rules & Assessment
| Criteria | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Profit Target | 25k: $1250; 50k: $3000; 100k: $6000; 150k: $9000 | $10,000 gross ceiling (Quick Pay) |
| Maximum Drawdown | Flex 25k: $1000; 50k: $2000; 100k: $3000; 150k: $4500 | $2,000/$3,000/$4,500 by account size; trailing, freezing at starting balance |
| Minimum Trading Days | Flex: 5; Pro: 1 | 5 |
| News Trading | — | No |
Fees & Pricing
| Option | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| $10K Account | — | — |
| $25K Account | — | — |
| $50K Account | — | — |
| $100K Account | — | 115-160/month |
| $200K Account | — | — |
| Refund Policy | — | No refunds after purchase |
| Coupons / Discount | Lucid Trading discount | TradeDay discount |
| Feature | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Trading Platforms | NinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Sierra Chart, ATAS, Bookmap, Quantower, Jigsaw, MotiveWave, R|Trader Pro, MultiCharts | — |
| Forex | Yes | No |
| Stocks | No | No |
| Indices | Yes | — |
| Commodities | Yes | No |
| Cryptocurrencies | No | No |
| Bonds | No | — |
| EA/Algo Trading | — | — |
Payout
Verdict
| Key Element | Lucid Trading | TradeDay |
|---|
| Strengths | 15-minute average payout speed, Dual plans for different experience levels, 10+ professional platforms, Crypto payout options, Large active community | No daily drawdown, earned split, transparent pass rates (36%), trader-friendly consistency rule, Day One payouts |
| Weaknesses | Max account size $150,000 smaller than competitors, LucidFlex payout caps on initial withdrawals, Futures-only, Daily loss limits on larger LucidPro accounts | $10,000 profit ceiling confiscates excess, 50/50 starting split, metals banned, Quick Pay converts to intraday when funded, monthly subscription model |
| Best For | Futures traders seeking rapid payouts and flexible challenge structures | Futures traders avoiding daily loss limits; transparent disclosure valued |
Verdict: Who each is best for: Lucid Trading — Futures traders seeking rapid payouts and flexible challenge structures. TradeDay — Futures traders avoiding daily loss limits; transparent disclosure valued.
FAQ
Which firm pays out faster, Lucid Trading or TradeDay?
Both prioritise speed. Lucid documents an average payout of around 15 minutes with Plaid, ADP and crypto options. TradeDay offers day-one payouts with no consistency requirement. Lucid wins on raw per-request speed; TradeDay wins on how soon and how freely you can start withdrawing.
Which firm has the higher profit split, Lucid or TradeDay?
It depends on scaling. Lucid pays a flat 90%, which beats TradeDay’s 80% starting point. TradeDay scales up to 95%, so a scaled TradeDay trader ends up ahead of Lucid’s flat rate.
Can I run multiple accounts with either firm?
TradeDay explicitly allows up to six simultaneous accounts with no activation fee. Lucid Trading funds per plan, so TradeDay is the better choice for traders who want to run several accounts at once.
How was this 2 companies Comparison Created?
This comparison was compiled using the published review data on JoinProp for each firm, along with each firm’s stated evaluation rules, account structures, platforms and payout terms as of 2026. Where a detail is not publicly disclosed, the cell notes this. Verify current terms directly with Lucid Trading and TradeDay before purchasing a challenge.
View More Elite Prop Firms Compared: The Trading Pit vs The5ers
