Lucid Trading vs Topstep – Prop Firm Comparison

Published: · Last updated:

Introduction

Lucid Trading and Topstep are both CME futures firms, but they appeal to opposite instincts: Lucid sells speed and scale, while Topstep sells heritage and education. Topstep, founded in Chicago in 2012, invented the Trading Combine evaluation that the industry later copied and has grown a community of 150,000+ traders with a deep educational ecosystem. Lucid Trading is the newer high-volume challenger, with 50,000+ funded traders, $60M+ paid out and the fastest average payout in the space at around 15 minutes, including cryptocurrency withdrawals. Both fund CME index, energy and metals contracts and both pay up to a 90% profit split, but the structures differ. Topstep runs its Trading Combine on $50K to $150K accounts with a trailing drawdown and an emphasis on consistency and coaching. Lucid funds $25K to $150K accounts through two plans, LucidFlex, which needs five qualifying days, and LucidPro, which can be passed in a single day, both using static max-loss limits. Platform choice is broader at Lucid, which supports 10+ platforms including NinjaTrader, Tradovate, CQG and Rithmic, while Topstep centres on its own TopstepX alongside NinjaTrader. On payouts, Lucid’s 15-minute model and crypto options outpace Topstep’s standard schedule. A trader who values the most established Combine model, structured education and a proven brand will choose Topstep; one who wants the fastest payouts, a lower entry point and the widest platform choice will prefer Lucid Trading.

FeatureLucid TradingTopstep
Lucid Trading Topstep
Founded2012
Profit Split90100% first $10,000, then 90/10
Maximum Account Size$150,000$150,000
Evaluation Phases21
Trustpilot Rating4.83.4
Expert Grade8.49
ProgramLucid TradingTopstep
Entry Level ProgramYesYes
Advanced ProgramYes
Scaling OptionsYesNo
Demo AccountNo
CriteriaLucid TradingTopstep
Profit Target25k: $1250; 50k: $3000; 100k: $6000; 150k: $90006%
Maximum DrawdownFlex 25k: $1000; 50k: $2000; 100k: $3000; 150k: $4500Trailing MLL: $2,000-$4,500
Minimum Trading DaysFlex: 5; Pro: 15
News TradingYes
OptionLucid TradingTopstep
$25K AccountUSD 135 / Pro Eval / One-time
$50K AccountUSD 185 / Pro Eval / One-timeUSD 49 / Trading Combine / Monthly
$100K AccountUSD 285 / Pro Eval / One-timeUSD 99 / Trading Combine / Monthly
$150K AccountUSD 370 / Pro Eval / One-timeUSD 149 / Trading Combine / Monthly
Coupons / DiscountLucid Trading discountTopstep discount
FeatureLucid TradingTopstep
Trading PlatformsNinjaTrader, Tradovate, TradingView, Sierra Chart, ATAS, Bookmap, Quantower, Jigsaw, MotiveWave, R|Trader Pro, MultiChartsTopstepX
ForexYesYes
StocksNoNo
IndicesYesYes
CommoditiesYesYes
CryptocurrenciesNoNo
BondsNoYes
EA/Algo TradingYes
FeatureLucid TradingTopstep
Payout Terms15-minute average via Plaid, ADP, or cryptoBi-weekly via ACH, wire, or Rise; $50 minimum
See all prop firm payouts →
Key ElementLucid TradingTopstep
Strengths15-minute average payout speed, Dual plans for different experience levels, 10+ professional platforms, Crypto payout options, Large active communityIndustry pioneer, generous first $10K profit split, no time limits, EAs permitted, no daily loss limit, $1B+ paid to traders
WeaknessesMax account size $150,000 smaller than competitors, LucidFlex payout caps on initial withdrawals, Futures-only, Daily loss limits on larger LucidPro accountsMonthly subscription fees compound, $149 activation fee, TopstepX platform exclusive, futures-only, trailing MLL can catch intraday profit-takers
Best ForFutures traders seeking rapid payouts and flexible challenge structuresSerious futures traders seeking established firm with forgiving evaluation

Conclusion and Final Recommendation

Choose Lucid Trading if you are futures traders seeking rapid payouts and flexible challenge structures. Choose Topstep if a shorter evaluation at 1 phase, a cheaper entry, from USD 49 and coverage of bonds that the other does not offer matter more to you. Neither firm is better in the abstract. The right choice depends on your strategy, your budget and the instruments you trade, so read both full reviews before you commit. Verify current rules and pricing on each firm’s own site before purchasing.

Frequently asked questions

How We Compared Lucid Trading and Topstep

Both firms on this page carry a JoinProp Rating out of 10. We produce that rating with the same 9-factor methodology we apply to every firm we review: payout reliability (20%), fee structure (15%), drawdown rules (15%), profit split (15%), evaluation terms (10%), trading rules (10%), support access and responsiveness (5%), scaling plan (5%), and track record and transparency (5%).

The inputs come from our firm reviews, not from this page. For each firm we work from the current terms and conditions rather than marketing pages, track rule and pricing changes over time, and read payout and support reports across Trustpilot, Reddit and Discord, looking for recurring patterns rather than isolated complaints. Every firm is re-checked at least every 90 days, or sooner after a material change. Affiliate relationships have no effect on any rating, and ratings are never sold.

The tables above show the evidence behind those factors. A few rows, including trading platforms, available instruments, maximum account size and demo availability, are there to help you judge fit and do not affect either rating.

Read our full ranking methodology

View More Elite Prop Firms Compared: The5ers vs The Trade Pool

JoinProp Lucid Trading and Topstep are both CME futures firms, but they appeal to opposite instincts: Lucid sells speed and scale, while Topstep sells heritage and education. Topstep, founded in Chicago in 2012, invented the Trading Combine evaluation that the industry later copied and has grown a community of 150,000+ traders with a deep educational ecosystem. Lucid Trading is the newer high-volume challenger, with 50,000+ funded traders, $60M+ paid out and the fastest average payout in the space at around 15 minutes, including cryptocurrency withdrawals. Both fund CME index, energy and metals contracts and both pay up to a 90% profit split, but the structures differ. Topstep runs its Trading Combine on $50K to $150K accounts with a trailing drawdown and an emphasis on consistency and coaching. Lucid funds $25K to $150K accounts through two plans, LucidFlex, which needs five qualifying days, and LucidPro, which can be passed in a single day, both using static max-loss limits. Platform choice is broader at Lucid, which supports 10+ platforms including NinjaTrader, Tradovate, CQG and Rithmic, while Topstep centres on its own TopstepX alongside NinjaTrader. On payouts, Lucid's 15-minute model and crypto options outpace Topstep's standard schedule. A trader who values the most established Combine model, structured education and a proven brand will choose Topstep; one who wants the fastest payouts, a lower entry point and the widest platform choice will prefer Lucid Trading.

About JoinProp

JoinProp is your trusted gateway to the world of proprietary trading. We provide clear, unbiased firm reviews, comparison tools, and educational content to help traders at all levels make smarter decisions and grow their trading careers. Whether you’re just getting started or scaling up, JoinProp is here to guide your journey.

FAQs