Goat Funded Trader vs Tradeify – Prop Firm Comparison
# Goat Funded Trader vs Tradeify – Prop Firm Comparison
Goat Funded Trader (GFT) and Tradeify represent two different philosophies in the prop trading world. GFT is a multi-asset firm covering forex, indices, metals, commodities, and crypto on MT5/TradeLocker – with flexible evaluation paths, swap-free accounts, and entry points starting at $1. Tradeify is a pure futures firm built for institutional-grade CME execution, offering 100% of your first $15,000 in profits and some of the fastest payout cycles in the industry.
Both launched in 2022. The comparison comes down to what you trade and what you value: GFT wins on asset breadth and accessibility; Tradeify wins on payout generosity and futures infrastructure.
—
1. Quick Overview
| Feature | Goat Funded Trader | Tradeify |
|---|---|---|
 |
 |
|
| Founded | 2022, Saint Lucia (Goat Funded LTD) | 2022, United States (founder: Brett Simba) |
| Markets | Forex, indices, metals, commodities, crypto | Futures only (CME, CBOT, COMEX, NYMEX) |
| Evaluation model | 1-Step, 2-Step, 3-Step, Instant Funding, Goat $1 | Growth (1-Step), Select (1-Step), Lightning Funded (instant) |
| Account sizes | $5,000 – $400,000 (scaling to $2,000,000) | Multiple tiers; scaling to $2,000,000 |
| Profit split | 80–90% baseline, scaling to 100% | 100% first $15,000, then 90% |
| Platforms | MetaTrader 5, TradeLocker, Match Trader | Tradovate, NinjaTrader, TradingView, Quantower, WealthCharts |
| Total payouts | $13 million+ | $125 million+ |
| Trustpilot | Not prominently published | 4.7/5 |
| Discount | See discounts | See discounts |
| Full Review | Read full review | Read full review |
—
2. Pricing & Plans
| Account Size | GFT 1-Step Fee | GFT 2-Step Fee | Tradeify Growth (monthly) | Tradeify Select (monthly) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $5,000 | $39 (one-time) | $29 (one-time) | $139/mo | $159/mo |
| $10,000 | $79 (one-time) | $59 (one-time) | ~$179/mo | ~$199/mo |
| $25,000 | $149 (one-time) | $119 (one-time) | ~$239/mo | ~$259/mo |
| $50,000 | $249 (one-time) | $199 (one-time) | ~$289/mo | ~$309/mo |
| $100,000 | $449 (one-time) | $369 (one-time) | $339/mo | $359/mo |
| $200,000 | $799 (one-time) | $649 (one-time) | N/A (check site) | N/A (check site) |
| Instant / no-eval | Instant Funding from $49 (one-time) | Lightning Funded – one-time fee (check site) | – | – |
Note: GFT uses one-time challenge fees; Tradeify uses recurring monthly subscriptions on Growth and Select. Over multiple months, Tradeify’s total cost can exceed GFT’s if the evaluation takes time.
—
3. Evaluation & Challenge Structure
| Parameter | Goat Funded Trader | Tradeify |
|---|---|---|
| Evaluation phases | 1-Step, 2-Step (8%/5%), 3-Step, or skip entirely (Instant) | 1-Step (Growth or Select) or skip entirely (Lightning Funded) |
| Profit target (1-Step) | 10% (1-Step) / 15% (Goat $1) | Varies by program – check tradeify.com |
| Minimum trading days | 3 days per phase | No minimum on most programs |
| Time limit | No time limit | No time limit |
| Daily drawdown | 4% daily drawdown limit (all programs) | EOD trailing drawdown – no published separate daily limit |
| Max drawdown (1-Step) | 6% trailing from highest equity | EOD trailing – amount varies by account size |
| Consistency rule | None stated for standard programs | 35% (Growth), 20% (Select, Lightning) – best day ≤ X% of cycle profits |
| Lowest entry point | $1 (Goat $1 challenge – $1,000 funded account) | Check tradeify.com for current lowest tier |
—
4. Drawdown & Risk Rules
| Rule | Goat Funded Trader | Tradeify |
|---|---|---|
| Drawdown type (1-Step) | Trailing from highest equity (intraday) | EOD trailing – trails from end-of-day high balance |
| Drawdown type (2-Step) | 10% static (balance-based) | EOD trailing on all programs |
| Daily drawdown limit | 4% per day (all programs) | Not separately stated – EOD trailing is the primary rule |
| Drawdown floor | Trailing floor rises with equity highs (intraday for 1-Step) | EOD trailing floor rises with each day’s closing balance |
| Hedging | Prohibited – both same-account and multi-account | Not permitted |
| Correlated instruments | Not specified | Trading correlated indices (e.g., ES + NQ) restricted under risk rules |
—
5. Profit Split & Payouts
| Parameter | Goat Funded Trader | Tradeify |
|---|---|---|
| Profit split | 80–90% baseline; scales to 100% for top performers | 100% of first $15,000 cumulative profits, then 90% |
| First payout cap | First 2 payouts capped at 6% of account size | No cap – 100% of profits up to $15K |
| Payout frequency | Bi-weekly (every 2 weeks) | Bi-weekly (Growth, Lightning); daily (Select) |
| Payout process | Requires trade documentation, contract signing, compliance verification | Direct through Tradovate – ACH/wire to linked bank account |
| Payment methods | Not fully specified – check goatfundedtrader.com | ACH bank transfer, wire transfer (via Tradovate) |
| Maximum funded capital | $400,000 (scaling to $2,000,000) | Scaling to $2,000,000 |
| Scaling trigger | Performance-based – consistent profits across payout cycles | Performance-based – check tradeify.com for current criteria |
—
6. Trading Rules
| Rule | Goat Funded Trader | Tradeify |
|---|---|---|
| Expert Advisors (EAs) | Permitted – must prove ownership of EA code; commercial challenge-passing EAs banned | Strictly prohibited in funded phase |
| Copy trading | Completely banned | Strictly prohibited |
| News trading | Allowed – accounts may be manually reviewed if large profits generated | Allowed – no hard restriction window; consistency rule may apply |
| Overnight holding | Permitted | Permitted (futures markets) |
| Weekend holding | Permitted | Prohibited – all positions must close by Friday market close |
| Leverage | Up to 1:100 during evaluations | Futures margin rules apply (CME/NFA standard) |
| Swap-free / Islamic accounts | Yes – available on all programs at no extra cost | Not applicable (futures – no swaps) |
| Max simultaneous accounts | Not specified | Up to 5 funded or simulated accounts |
—
7. Platforms & Markets
| Feature | Goat Funded Trader | Tradeify |
|---|---|---|
| Trading platforms | MetaTrader 5 (MT5), TradeLocker, Match Trader | Tradovate, NinjaTrader, TradingView, Quantower, WealthCharts |
| Asset classes | Forex, indices, metals, commodities, cryptocurrencies | Futures only – no forex CFDs, no spot crypto |
| Specific instruments | EUR/USD, US30, NAS100, XAUUSD, crude oil, BTC/ETH pairs | ES, NQ, YM, RTY, GC, CL, 6E, BTC/ETH futures, Treasuries, VIX |
| Broker backend | Proprietary – not backed by regulated broker | Tradovate (CFTC/NFA regulated broker) |
| Mobile trading | MT5, TradeLocker, Match Trader – all have mobile apps | Tradovate web/mobile; NinjaTrader mobile available |
| Platform cost | Included in subscription | Tradovate $16/mo (Level 1) or $41/mo bundle; other platforms have own fees |
—
8. Company & Trust
| Detail | Goat Funded Trader | Tradeify |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 2022 | 2022 |
| Legal entity | Goat Funded LTD (Saint Lucia, No. 2025-00240); Wishes Tower International Limited (Hong Kong) | US-based; broker: Tradovate (CFTC/NFA regulated) |
| Regulation | None – registered in Saint Lucia and Hong Kong, no financial regulator | Unregulated prop firm; underlying broker Tradovate is CFTC/NFA regulated |
| Total payouts | $13 million+ | $125 million+ |
| Community size | 250,000+ traders globally | Not specified |
| Trustpilot | Not prominently published | 4.7/5 – one of the highest in futures prop |
| Founder | Not publicly named | Brett Simba – professional trader and educator |
—
9. Verdict: Which Firm Is Right for You?
| Trader Type | Better Choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Forex / multi-asset trader | Goat Funded Trader | Tradeify is futures-only – GFT covers forex, indices, metals, commodities, and crypto |
| Futures-focused trader | Tradeify | Purpose-built for CME futures; 100% first $15K payout; CFTC-regulated broker backend |
| EA / algorithmic trader | Goat Funded Trader | EAs permitted (with ownership proof); Tradeify bans EAs in funded phase entirely |
| Trader wanting maximum profit split | Tradeify | 100% of first $15K per account is better than GFT’s 80–90% baseline |
| Islamic / swap-free trader | Goat Funded Trader | Swap-free accounts available on all programs at no extra cost; not relevant for futures |
| Trader on an ultra-tight budget | Goat Funded Trader | Goat $1 account starts at $1; GFT 2-Step from $29; Tradeify requires ongoing monthly fees |
| Weekend position holder | Goat Funded Trader | Weekend holding permitted; Tradeify requires all positions closed by Friday close |
| Trader who values trust & payout track record | Tradeify | $125M+ payouts vs GFT’s $13M+; Trustpilot 4.7/5 vs no published rating |
Bottom line: GFT and Tradeify rarely compete for the same trader. If you trade forex, CFDs, or crypto – GFT is the obvious choice; Tradeify doesn’t offer these markets. If you trade CME futures, Tradeify’s 100% first-$15K payout, regulated broker infrastructure, and 4.7/5 Trustpilot make it the stronger pick. The key trade-off at Tradeify is the EA ban and weekend close requirement – if your strategy relies on either, GFT is the better fit despite the lower baseline profit split.
