Take Profit Trader vs TradeDay - Prop Firm Comparison
Introduction
Most futures prop comparisons hinge on who pays faster, but Take Profit Trader and TradeDay both offer day-one payouts, so that usual tiebreaker is off the table here. With payout speed roughly even, the real separation is in platforms, news rules, and how each firm handles drawdown and scaling.
Take Profit Trader, founded in Orlando in 2021 by James Sixsmith, is the more flexible of the two on the trading side. It supports 15+ platforms (NinjaTrader, Tradovate, Rithmic, ATAS, Bookmap and more), permits news trading with no blackout, and removed its intraday daily-loss limit in 2025, leaving only an end-of-day trailing drawdown. Its split runs 80% on PRO and 90% once you upgrade to PRO+.
TradeDay, founded in Chicago in 2020, answers with structure and headroom. It pays 80% from day one and scales to 95%, a higher ceiling than Take Profit Trader, lets you choose between intraday, end-of-day or static drawdown, and allows up to six simultaneous accounts. The trade-offs are no news trading during major releases, a 5-day minimum, and a tighter platform list (Tradovate, NinjaTrader 8, TradingView, Jigsaw).
So this one is genuinely close. Pick Take Profit Trader if you want the widest platform choice, the freedom to trade the news, and a $25K entry point. Pick TradeDay if you want the higher 95% split ceiling, a choice of drawdown styles, and the ability to run several accounts at once. Both pay fast and both trade CME futures only, so it comes down to which set of trade-offs fits how you actually trade.
Quick Facts
| Feature | Take Profit Trader Review | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
 |  | |
| Founded | 2021 | — |
| Profit Split | 80/20 PRO, 90/10 PRO+ | 50/50 below $4,000; 80/20 above $4,000; 90/10 at Funded Live |
| Maximum Account Size | $150,000 | — |
| Evaluation Phases | 1 | 1 |
| Trustpilot Rating | 4.4 | 4.6 |
| Expert Grade | 7.5 | 8.9 |
Program Types
| Program | Take Profit Trader Review | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Entry Level Program | Yes | Yes |
| Advanced Program | Yes | Yes |
| Scaling Options | Yes | Yes |
| Demo Account | Yes | Yes |
Rules & Assessment
| Criteria | Take Profit Trader Review | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Profit Target | Varies by account size | $10,000 gross ceiling (Quick Pay) |
| Maximum Drawdown | EOD trailing drawdown | $2,000/$3,000/$4,500 by account size; trailing, freezing at starting balance |
| Minimum Trading Days | — | 5 |
| News Trading | Yes | No |
Fees & Pricing
| Option | Take Profit Trader Review | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| $10K Account | — | — |
| $25K Account | $150 | — |
| $50K Account | $170 | — |
| $100K Account | $270 | 115-160/month |
| $200K Account | — | — |
| Refund Policy | No | No refunds after purchase |
| Coupons / Discount | Take Profit Trader Review discount | TradeDay discount |
Platforms & Markets
| Feature | Take Profit Trader Review | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Trading Platforms | NinjaTrader, Tradovate, Rithmic, ATAS, Bookmap, Quantower, Sierra Chart, Jigsaw Daytradr | — |
| Forex | Yes | No |
| Stocks | Yes | No |
| Indices | Yes | — |
| Commodities | Yes | No |
| Cryptocurrencies | No | No |
| Bonds | Yes | — |
| EA/Algo Trading | Yes | — |
Payout
| Feature | Take Profit Trader Review | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Payout Terms | Day-one withdrawals; $50 fee under $250 | Minimum $250 |
| See all prop firm payouts → | ||
Verdict
| Key Element | Take Profit Trader Review | TradeDay |
|---|---|---|
| Strengths | Day-one payouts, No intraday daily loss limit, 1-step evaluation, News trading permitted, Multiple platform support | No daily drawdown, earned split, transparent pass rates (36%), trader-friendly consistency rule, Day One payouts |
| Weaknesses | PRO simulated until PRO+ invite, $130 activation fee, Higher monthly fees, 50% consistency rule, No automation permitted, Weekly trading requirement | $10,000 profit ceiling confiscates excess, 50/50 starting split, metals banned, Quick Pay converts to intraday when funded, monthly subscription model |
| Best For | Active futures traders valuing payout speed and trading flexibility | Futures traders avoiding daily loss limits; transparent disclosure valued |
FAQ
Are Take Profit Trader and TradeDay both futures-only?
Yes. Both fund traders exclusively on CME Group futures – index, energy, metals, agricultural and currency contracts. Neither offers forex or CFD funded accounts.
Which firm pays out faster?
Both are excellent here. Take Profit Trader offers day-one payouts on PRO accounts, and TradeDay also offers day-one payouts with no consistency rule. They are among the fastest-paying futures firms available.
Which firm has the better profit split?
TradeDay starts at 80% from day one and scales up to 95%. Take Profit Trader pays 80% on PRO and 90% on PRO+. TradeDay has the higher long-run ceiling, while Take Profit Trader reaches 90% via its PRO+ tier.
Can I trade during news on each firm?
Take Profit Trader permits news trading with no blackout window, making it strong for NFP, FOMC and CPI strategies. TradeDay does not allow trading during major news releases.
Which firm has more platform choice?
Take Profit Trader supports 15+ platforms including NinjaTrader, Tradovate, Rithmic, ATAS and Bookmap. TradeDay supports Tradovate, NinjaTrader 8, TradingView and Jigsaw.
Can I run more than one account at Take Profit Trader or TradeDay?
TradeDay allows up to six simultaneous funded accounts, which suits traders who want to diversify or scale across accounts. Take Profit Trader instead moves you from PRO to PRO+ (and a 90% split) once you bank $5,000 in profit, focusing on growing a single account tier rather than running many at once.
Which firm gives more control over the drawdown rules?
TradeDay does. It lets you pick between intraday, end-of-day or static drawdown, with fixed limits of $2,000, $3,000 or $4,000 depending on the account. Take Profit Trader keeps it simpler, with a single end-of-day trailing drawdown and no intraday daily-loss limit since 2025.
How was this 2 companies Comparison Created?
This comparison was compiled using the published review data on JoinProp for each firm. All figures – account sizes, profit splits, drawdown rules, platforms and payout structures – are taken from each firm’s review page. Where a detail is not publicly disclosed, the cell reads “Not specified.” Verify current terms directly with Take Profit Trader and TradeDay before purchasing a challenge.
Related comparison: Topstep vs TradeDay – Prop Firm Comparison
View More Elite Prop Firms Compared: FTMO vs The Trade Pool
