Topstep vs Blue Guardian – Elite Prop Firms Comparison

Published: · Last updated:

Introduction

Topstep and Blue Guardian target very different traders. Topstep, founded in Chicago in 2012, is the original CME-futures prop firm – futures-only, runs on its proprietary TopstepX platform, with more than a billion dollars paid out to funded traders. Blue Guardian (founded September 2021, headquartered in Dubai Silicon Oasis under Iconic Exchange FZCO, CEO Sean Baiton) is a multi-asset Forex / indices / commodities / crypto / stocks firm with two-phase challenges, account sizes from $10,000 to $200,000, and scaling up to $4,000,000. One important rule difference upfront: Blue Guardian does not permit EAs or automated trading systems, while Topstep does. The two firms barely overlap on instruments, so the choice mostly depends on what (and how) you trade.

FeatureTopstepBlue Guardian
Topstep Blue Guardian
Founded20122021
Profit Split90% trader share; first-$10,000 lifetime-profit exception for traders who joined the new dashboard before Jan 12, 2026CFD: Standard evaluations 85%, Instant Standard/2 Step Nano/BNPL 80%, Starter 90%; eligible add-ons 90%, 1 Step Nano lists 100%. Futures 90%
Maximum Account Size$150,000$400,000
Evaluation Phases1CFD 0-2 on current core models, legacy 3-Step; Futures Standard/Reserve/Express 1, Direct 0; Live earned by review
Trustpilot Rating3.4
Expert Grade98.1
ProgramTopstepBlue Guardian
Entry Level ProgramYesYes
Advanced ProgramYes
Scaling OptionsNoYes
Demo AccountNoYes
CriteriaTopstepBlue Guardian
Profit Target
Maximum DrawdownTrailing MLL: $2,000-$4,500CFD core: 5-8% trailing or 8-10% static by model. Futures $100K: Standard/Direct $3.5k, Reserve $3k, Express $2.5k EOD (current purchase rules); buffers/locks apply
Minimum Trading DaysTrading Combine can pass in as few as 2 days, subject to 55% consistency; funded payout paths have separate day requirementsCFD model/stage dependent: Standard evaluation 3 qualifying days, Instant and 1 Step Nano funded 5, 2 Step Nano none. Futures Reserve payouts require 5 winning days; other gates vary
News TradingYesCFD challenges allowed, core funded +/-5-minute high-impact restrictions; Starter exception. Futures simulated allowed; Live prohibited
Daily Loss Limit
Consistency / Best Day Rule
Maximum Contracts
OptionTopstepBlue Guardian
CFD $5,000 Account


CFD $10,000 Account


CFD $25,000 Account



CFD $50,000 Account



CFD $100,000 Account



CFD $200,000 Account



CFD $300,000 Account
CFD $400,000 Account
Futures $50K Account
Futures $100K Account
Futures $150K Account
Futures $25,000 Account


Futures $50,000 Account


Futures $100,000 Account


Futures $150,000 Account


Refund PolicyCFD eligible purchases from 21 Jan 2026: completed evaluation fee refunded after fourth payout; prior hard breach forfeits, Instant Starter excluded
Coupons / DiscountTopstep discountBlue Guardian discount
FeatureTopstepBlue Guardian
Trading PlatformsTopstepX; Quantower connectivity for Trading Combine and Express Funded accountsMetaTrader 5, Match-Trader, TradeLocker, TradingView, Tradovate, NinjaTrader, DeepCharts
ForexCurrency futures, not spot ForexYes
StocksNoNo
IndicesYesYes
CommoditiesYesYes
CryptocurrenciesNoYes
BondsYesNo
EA/Algo TradingYesCFD personal-strategy EAs allowed; copying only legally owned accounts. Futures own-account copying allowed; no third-party management
FeatureTopstepBlue Guardian
Payout Terms$125 minimum; eligibility by funded-account path, not a bi-weekly schedule. XFA Standard: 5 winning days of $150+; XFA Consistency: 3 trading days and 40% consistency. Balance limits, account caps and method availability apply.CFD 14-day standard, 7-day options/Nano, Instant eligibility gates; crypto $100/Rise $500 minimum, 3% fee, first two $10k caps at $200k+. Futures caps/buffers by size: Standard 3-day, Reserve 5 winning days/50% profit, Express daily, Direct profit goals; Live review discretionary
See all prop firm payouts →
Key ElementTopstepBlue Guardian
StrengthsTrading Combine has no maximum completion deadline while the subscription remains active; automated strategies permitted subject to rules; 90% current trader share; Standard or Consistency Express payout paths. Daily-loss-limit arrangements vary.CFD static drawdown options; separate CFD and Futures programs; own-account copying; Futures Reserve optional daily-loss removal
WeaknessesRecurring Combine subscription; $149 XFA activation on Standard pricing path; futures-only; end-of-day trailing MLL can be breached intraday on unrealised lossesFunded CFD news restrictions and Shield penalties; consistency/day/buffer gates; CFD processing fee and selected caps; Futures size-specific caps; conflicting marketing/help details
Best ForSerious futures traders seeking established firm with forgiving evaluationTraders matching the exact market, model and purchase-date rules to their risk and withdrawal needs

Conclusion and Final Recommendation

Choose Topstep if you want a cheaper entry, from USD 49 and coverage of bonds that the other does not offer. Choose Blue Guardian if a larger funded ceiling at $400K, a demo account to test the platform first and coverage of cryptocurrencies that the other does not offer matter more to you. Neither firm is better in the abstract. The right choice depends on your strategy, your budget and the instruments you trade, so read both full reviews before you commit. Verify current rules and pricing on each firm’s own site before purchasing.

Frequently asked questions

How We Compared Topstep and Blue Guardian

Both firms carry a JoinProp Rating out of 10, scored on the same nine weighted factors, led by payout reliability at 20%, then fee structure, drawdown rules and profit split at 15% each. The scores come from our own firm reviews, built from each firm’s current terms rather than its marketing pages and re-checked at least every 90 days. Affiliate relationships have no effect on any rating, and ratings are never sold. The tables above are the evidence behind those scores. Read our full ranking methodology.

View More Elite Prop Firms Compared

Topstep vs One Funded – Elite Prop Firms Comparison