The Concept Trading vs TradeDay: Elite Prop Firms Comparison
Introduction
The Concept Trading and TradeDay are leading proprietary trading firms offering funded trader programs for aspiring financial market participants. The Concept Trading stands out as an ASIC-regulated firm (via Vested Equities) with five evaluation programs (Foundation, Traditional, Premier, Empire, Xtreme) scaling up to $50 million in funded capital, earning a solid 4.6/5 on Trustpilot from 443 verified reviews (April 2026). TradeDay is a futures-only specialist (Chicago, founded 2020) with a single-step evaluation across Intraday, EOD, and Static drawdown variants, maintaining a strong 4.6/5 Trustpilot rating from 1,354+ reviews (April 2026). Both organizations provide pathways to trade with significant capital without risking personal funds, though they differ in their approach to evaluations, fee structures, and trader support systems.
Quick Comparison |
||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | The Concept Trading | TradeDay |
 |
 |
|
| Founded | 2021 (Australia) | 2020 (Chicago) |
| Trustpilot Rating | 4.6/5 (443 reviews, April 2026) | 4.6/5 (1,354+ reviews, April 2026) |
| Minimum Account Size | Foundation from $65; Traditional from $97 (program-tiered, scales to $50M via Xtreme) | $50,000 (smallest TradeDay account; max published size $150K, futures-only) |
| Profit Split | 50% to 90% (90% Lock Rule available) | 80% Day One, up to 95% |
| Evaluation Phases | 1-Step on Traditional/Premier/Empire/Xtreme; 2-Stage on Foundation; Instant Funded on select programs | Single-step (Intraday, EOD, or Static drawdown variants at signup) |
| Review | Read full review | Read full review |
Program Types – Which experience fits your goals? |
||
|---|---|---|
| Program | The Concept Trading | TradeDay |
| Standard Evaluation | Five programs: Traditional, Premier, Empire, Xtreme (1-step); Foundation (2-stage entry-level) | Single-step evaluation across Intraday, EOD, and Static drawdown variants (no verification phase) |
| Express / Instant Funding | Instant Funded available on Traditional, Premier, and Xtreme programs (skip evaluation entirely) | Fast-Track Option: premium fee skips directly to funded account upon meeting criteria |
| Account Sizes | Program-tiered: Foundation from $65; Traditional from $97 (scales to $2M); Premier from $297 (to $10M); Empire from $997 (to $20M); Xtreme from $300 (to $50M) | $50K, $100K, $150K only (futures-only; no $10K/$25K/$200K options) |
| Scaling Opportunities | Up to $50M via Xtreme (80% per level across 11 steps); Traditional/Premier ~70% per level; Empire ~50% | Not publicly disclosed; max published account size is $150K |
| Demo / Entry Path | Foundation program serves as the low-cost entry path (from $65, 2-stage, 3-day minimum) | Free trial account available to test trading conditions before purchase |
Assessment Criteria – How can you pass the test? |
||
|---|---|---|
| Criteria | The Concept Trading | TradeDay |
| Profit Targets | Traditional 6%, Premier 7%, Empire 10%, Xtreme 6% (1-step); Foundation 2-stage | 6% across all plans (Intraday / EOD / Static), single-step |
| Time Limits | No time limits on any program | No time limits on any plan |
| Daily Drawdown | None – TCT enforces static drawdown only | No fixed daily-loss limit (only trailing or static maximum drawdown) |
| Maximum Drawdown | Static drawdown: Traditional 4%, Premier 5%, Empire 10%, Xtreme 3% | Trailing $2K / $3K / $4K on $50K / $100K / $150K (Intraday, EOD, or Static at signup) |
| Minimum Trading Days | None on Traditional, Premier, Empire, Xtreme; Foundation requires 3 trading days | Minimum 5 trading days (single-step) |
| Consistency Rules | One rule only: do not breach the static drawdown limit | Trailing drawdown enforces discipline naturally; no separate consistency rule |
| News Trading | Fully allowed (all trading styles permitted: scalping, news, hedging, EAs, algorithmic) | Restricted on funded accounts during high-impact event windows |
Fees and Pricing – How much will you pay? |
||
|---|---|---|
| Option | The Concept Trading | TradeDay |
| $25K Account | Available via Traditional or Foundation (program-tiered pricing) | Not offered ($50K TradeDay minimum) |
| $50K Account | Premier from $297 (one-time, 1-step) | From $87/mo (SAVE30) or $125/mo full price (Intraday plan) |
| $100K Account | Empire from $997 (one-time, 1-step, scales to $20M) | $140/mo (SAVE30) or $200/mo full price (Intraday plan) |
| $200K+ Account | Xtreme from $300 (one-time, scales up to $50M across 11 levels) | Not offered (max published TradeDay account size is $150K) |
| Express / Premium Option | Instant Funding skips evaluation on Traditional, Premier, and Xtreme programs | Fast-Track Option: premium fee skips directly to funded account upon meeting criteria |
| Pricing Model | One-time evaluation fee per program (no monthly fees) | Monthly subscription pricing for the evaluation plan (NOT a separate post-funding platform fee) |
| Coupons | Coupon Code | Coupon Code |
| Review | Read full review | Read full review |
Platforms/Tools – What can you use? |
||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | The Concept Trading | TradeDay |
| Trading Platforms | MetaTrader 5 via The Concept Limited broker (Pro Spreads with $6 round-turn commission or Normal Spreads with no commission) | Tradovate, NinjaTrader 8, TradingView, Jigsaw (futures platforms; no MT) |
| Proprietary Tools | ASIC-regulated trader dashboard with one-rule (static drawdown) interface | Performance analytics dashboard with trade statistics and real-time monitoring |
| Mobile Trading | Available via the MT5 mobile app | Available via Tradovate, NinjaTrader, and TradingView mobile apps |
| Performance Analytics | Standard performance tracking via the trader dashboard | Trading journal integration, custom indicators, real-time trade monitoring |
| Educational Resources | Trading courses, blog, and market analysis content | Trader Development Program: webinars, trading guides, strategy sessions, and trading psychology workshops |
| EAs / Automation | All trading styles permitted (scalping, news, hedging, EAs, algorithmic) – no public API limits stated | Reasonable automation policies apply (consult support; no public EA ban) |
Available Options/Products |
||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | The Concept Trading | TradeDay |
| Available Markets | Forex, Indices, Commodities, Crypto (CFD-based via The Concept Limited broker) | Futures only: Equity Index, FX Futures, Energy, Metals, Agricultural, Bond futures (no spot Forex, no crypto, no cash stocks) |
| Leverage / Position Limits | Up to 1:200 on Traditional, Premier, Empire programs; capped at 1:30 on Xtreme | Futures position limits: 5 / 10 / 15 standard contracts (or 50 micros) on $50K / $100K / $150K accounts |
| Trading Hours | Standard CFD market hours; no restrictions on overnight or weekend position holding | Official futures-market hours per instrument; no overnight or weekend position holding |
| Account Types | Five evaluation programs (Foundation, Traditional, Premier, Empire, Xtreme) plus Instant Funded path | Intraday, EOD, and Static drawdown variants on the single-step plan |
| Community Features | Australian trader community; ASIC-regulated firm structure | Trader Development Program with mentorship-style coaching |
| Special Programs | 90% Lock Rule (lock account to retain 90% of future profits); Instant Funded path | Trader Development Program (1-on-1 coaching, weekly strategy sessions, trading psychology workshops) |
Technical Capabilities/Performance |
||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | The Concept Trading | TradeDay |
| Execution Speed | Not published by firm | Not published by firm |
| Server Locations | Not published (executed via The Concept Limited broker infrastructure) | Not published (futures platforms hosted by Tradovate / NinjaTrader / Rithmic) |
| Spreads / Commissions | Pro Spreads: tighter FX with $6 round-turn commission ($3 entry + $3 exit; no markup); Normal Spreads: wider, no commission | Futures use per-contract commissions (typically $0.50–$3 round-turn plus CME/NYMEX exchange fees) |
| Platform Stability | Not published | Not published |
| Data Feeds | Standard MetaTrader 5 feeds via broker | Tradovate / Rithmic / NinjaTrader feeds (futures-grade) |
| VPS Options | Not separately advertised by firm | Not separately advertised by firm |
| Backtesting Capabilities | MT5 strategy tester | Tradovate, NinjaTrader 8, and TradingView backtesters |
Customer Support and Community |
||
|---|---|---|
| Feature | The Concept Trading | TradeDay |
| Support Hours | Monday to Friday, 9am–5pm AEST (Australian Eastern Standard Time) | 24/7 via live chat and email (support@tradeday.com) |
| Response Time | Standard email response within Australian business hours | 24/7 live chat available; email response varies by query |
| Languages Supported | Not specified by firm | Not specified by firm |
| Trader Community | Australian-based trader community via The Concept Trading channels | Trader Development Program with mentorship-style coaching and weekly strategy sessions |
| Educational Resources | Basic guides and tutorials | Comprehensive academy with structured learning paths |
| Mentoring Options | Not separately advertised by firm | Available via Trader Development Program (1-on-1 coaching, weekly strategy sessions, trading psychology workshops) |
Conclusion and Final Recommendation |
||
|---|---|---|
| Key Element | The Concept Trading | TradeDay |
| Strengths | ASIC-regulated firm (via Vested Equities); five evaluation programs scaling up to $50M; static drawdown only (no daily DD); 90% Lock Rule; all trading styles permitted; one-time evaluation fees with no monthly costs | Futures-only specialist; 80% Day One profit split (up to 95%); Day One Payouts with no consistency requirement; single-step evaluation; up to 6 simultaneous accounts; Trader Development Program with 1-on-1 coaching |
| Weaknesses | MetaTrader 5 only; Xtreme program leverage capped at 1:30; primarily Australian-time-zone support; relatively newer firm (founded 2021) | Futures-only – no spot Forex, stocks, or crypto; Day Trade only (no overnight or weekend holds); monthly subscription pricing; account sizes capped at $150K; news trading restricted during high-impact events |
| Best For | Experienced CFD/Forex traders seeking ASIC-regulated structure, maximum trading freedom (no daily DD, no style restrictions), and aggressive scaling up to $50M via the Xtreme program | Active futures traders comfortable with Tradovate, NinjaTrader 8, TradingView, or Jigsaw who want a single-step evaluation, Day One Payouts, and 1-on-1 coaching via the Trader Development Program |
| Final Grade | 4.6/5 | 4.7/5 |
| Discount Codes | Coupon Code | Coupon Code |
| Review | Read full review | Read full review |
FAQ
What makes The Concept Trading popular among users?
The Concept Trading’s popularity stems from its ASIC-regulated structure (via Vested Equities under AFSL 478987), its single-step evaluation across most programs (Traditional, Premier, Empire, Xtreme), and its single-rule simplicity: do not breach the static drawdown limit. Traders appreciate having no daily drawdown limit, no restrictions on trading style (scalping, hedging, news, and EAs are all permitted), one-time evaluation fees with no monthly costs, and the 90% Lock Rule that lets you secure 90% of future profits from any chosen account level. Founded 2021 in Australia, TCT scales accounts up to $50 million via its Xtreme program.
How does TradeDay differ from other similar organizations?
TradeDay distinguishes itself as a futures-only specialist focused on disciplined day traders. Founded in 2020 in Chicago by James Thorpe and Steve Miley, it offers a single-step evaluation across three drawdown variants (Intraday, EOD, Static) on three account sizes ($50K, $100K, $150K) priced as a monthly subscription. Its futures platforms – Tradovate, NinjaTrader 8, TradingView, and Jigsaw – replace MetaTrader for serious futures execution. Standout features include 80% Day One profit splits (up to 95%), Day One Payouts with no consistency requirement, up to 6 simultaneous accounts, and the Trader Development Program for 1-on-1 coaching. TradeDay is Day Trade only – no overnight or weekend position holding.
Which evaluation process is easier to pass – The Concept Trading or TradeDay?
Both firms use single-step evaluations, but with very different rule structures. The Concept Trading enforces one rule only: do not breach the static drawdown limit (4% on Traditional, 5% Premier, 10% Empire, 3% Xtreme) with no daily loss cap and no minimum trading days on Traditional/Premier/Empire/Xtreme. Profit targets are 6% Traditional, 7% Premier, 10% Empire, 6% Xtreme. TradeDay also runs a single-step evaluation with a 6% profit target across all plans (Intraday / EOD / Static) and a minimum 5 trading days, with a trailing drawdown of $2K / $3K / $4K on $50K / $100K / $150K accounts and no fixed daily-loss limit. TCT also offers Instant Funded paths on Traditional, Premier, and Xtreme that skip the evaluation entirely.
Do these companies actually pay out profits to successful traders?
Yes, both firms pay out funded traders. The Concept Trading offers weekly payouts at the top level of any program or under the 90% Lock Rule; otherwise traders receive their profit share each time they hit the scaling target, plus one additional monthly withdrawal allowed (per TCT FAQ). Payment methods include Bank Transfer, Crypto, Revolut, and PayPal. TradeDay advertises Day One Payouts – withdrawals available from day one of funded trading with no consistency requirement. Trustpilot ratings (verified April 2026): The Concept Trading 4.6/5 from 443 reviews; TradeDay 4.6/5 from 1,354+ reviews.
Are there any hidden fees I should be aware of when joining either company?
The two firms use fundamentally different pricing models. The Concept Trading charges a one-time evaluation fee per program (Foundation from $65; Traditional from $97; Premier from $297; Empire from $997; Xtreme from $300) with no monthly fees. TradeDay uses a monthly subscription model for the evaluation plan itself – for example, the $50K Intraday plan is $87/mo with the SAVE30 code or $125/mo at full price; this monthly cost is the evaluation fee structure rather than a separate post-funding platform fee. A reset costs $99 mid-cycle or is free at the next monthly renewal. Neither firm publishes inactivity-fee policies on its public marketing pages; consult the live terms at signup.
How was this 2 companies Comparison Created?
1. We Collect
Our research team gathered comprehensive data directly from The Concept Trading and TradeDay official websites, legal documents, and terms of service. We supplemented this with verified user reviews from Trustpilot, TrustPeer, and specialized trading forums. Additionally, we conducted interviews with current and former funded traders from both organizations to gain firsthand insights into the actual user experience beyond marketing claims. We monitored both companies’ social media presence and community discussions to identify recurring themes and common experiences.
2. We Examine
All collected information underwent rigorous verification by our team of professional traders and financial industry experts. We cross-referenced company claims with actual user experiences and independently tested aspects of both platforms when possible. Our analysts examined the fine print of all agreements, focusing particularly on profit calculation methods, withdrawal policies, and rule enforcement patterns. We applied consistent evaluation criteria across both organizations to ensure fair and balanced comparison points.
3. We Score
Our scoring methodology employs a weighted system that prioritizes the factors most important to traders: transparency of rules (25%), value proposition including fees and profit splits (25%), platform reliability and execution quality (20%), educational resources and community support (15%), and customer service responsiveness (15%). Each category contains multiple sub-metrics scored on a 1-5 scale. The final scores represent the aggregate performance across all categories, with particular emphasis on verified user outcomes rather than company promises.
4. You Choose
This comparison serves as a starting point for your research, not as a definitive answer for every trader. Consider your specific trading style, experience level, and financial goals when making your decision. The Concept Trading may be better suited if you value simplicity, lower ongoing costs, and more lenient evaluation metrics. TradeDay might be preferable if you prioritize advanced tools, educational resources, and faster scaling opportunities. We recommend visiting both companies’ websites, testing their demo environments if available, and reaching out to their support teams with specific questions relevant to your situation before making a commitment.
View More Elite Prop Firms Compared: The5ers vs FTM
